The Best Cat Toys For Keeping Your Kitties Engaged

Although your cat might prefer a cardboard box than a cat toy, you shouldn’t assume that she doesn’t enjoy playing with the toy every now and then.

They key to keeping your cat engaged and entertained to have a variety of the best cat toys that will keep her attention during playtime, which is pretty important when you are trying to forge a bond with your kitty.

Young Cat Playing With Mouse Toy

Pay attention to how your cat behaves during playtime—see if they are stalking or pouncing. This “playful attacking” is great for stimulating their natural predator-like behavior.

What Are The Best Cat Toys

So, what are some of the best cat toys? Well, that’s where things get a little tricky simply because there are so many types of toys on the market. These toys fit into categories like:

  • Fishing poles/teasers
  • Mice and Balls
  • Catnip toys
  • Scratchers
  • Interactive toys
  • Household items

When you’re trying to decide what to pick up for your cat, you’ll want to take into consideration things like:

  • Safety and Durability – When you’re getting toys for your cat, you’ll want to look at the toy itself and check for pieces that could come off and swallowed, sharp points, and something that could potentially hurt the cat. If you’re looking at stuffed cat toys, make sure the seams are done well, and there’s no chance your cat could get at the stuffing and possibly ingest it.

Cat Playing With Ball of Wool

  • Type of Cat Toy – As much as we want to spend as much time as we can playing with our kitties, sometimes that isn’t always conducive to our daily lives. This is when you want to find a few cat toys that encourage independent play. Things like bells, balls, and even automated cat toys can be a great option.
  • The Cat’s Movement – Cats are natural born predators, so when it comes to choosing a toy that will appeal to them, the toy’s movement should mimic how the prey moves. This means that you’re going to want to get a toy that will hop, wiggle on the floor, or flutter in the air. All of these things are key elements you should consider when you’re looking for the best interactive cat toys that will keep your kitty’s attention.
  • The size of the Toy – Cat’s aren’t big creatures, so you aren’t going to want to get a cat toy that is too large for them. Of course, if you’re planning on getting a kitty castle, then that’s a different story. However, you don’t want to get a huge bouncy ball for a tiny kitten, right? Of course not! Keep the size of the toy about the size of your cat.
  • Sound – Sometimes cats are drawn to noise, and sometimes they aren’t. Before you purchase any electronic cat toys that make noise, you should first consider your cat’s personality. If your cat is shy and scares easily, you won’t want to get a toy that makes a lot of noise. Cat’s hearing is incredibly sensitive, and they can pick up on sounds that we may not even hear. Remember, a cat’s prey typically emits high-pitched squeaks or ultrasonic sounds, and these noises could irritate your cat, even if it is in the form of a unique cat toy.
  • Catnip Toys – There are some toys that include catnip that can have a tendency to draw your cat in. Keep in mind that some cats simply don’t respond to the catnip, so before you purchase a toy that includes catnip, you’ll first want to try catnip with your kitty just to see how they react before you spend money on a toy.

What To Avoid When Choosing A Toy For Your Cat

Unfortunately, not every toy or homemade toy is going to be suitable for your kitty. What are some of these things that you’ll want to avoid giving your cat?

Frighten Cat in Paper Bag

Household objects like:

  • String, yarn, ribbons or dental floss
  • Paperclips
  • Pins and needles
  • Other things that your cat could chew and choke on
  • Plastic bags
  • Rubber bands

Toys with glittery pieces, as they could swallow it and it could be harmful to their digestion :

  • Toys that have beans or foam beads as filling
  • Brittle plastic that the cat could rip and swallow
  • Paper products like tissues, napkins, or regular paper

The Best Cat Toys Under $60

So with all of this talk of what kind of toys you could get your pet (and what not to let them play with), we’ve chosen three of the best cat toys.

These are the toys that our cats seem to get the most enjoyment out of, but also these toys are favored by other cat owners as well. Keep reading to read our brief review of.

​*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table

Product Name Our Rating Picture Learn More
Easyology Pets Premium Cat Tunnel Toy Maze Crinkle Chute Easyology Pets Premium Cat Tunnel Toy Maze Crinkle Chute in Living Room CHECK PRICES
Pioneer Smart Cat Ultimate Scratching Post Pioneer Smart Cat Ultimate Scratching Post on White Background CHECK PRICES
Cat Tree Scratcher Play House Condo Cats on Cat Tree Scratcher Play House Condo CHECK PRICES

Easyology Pets Premium Cat Tunnel Toy Maze Crinkle Chute

This toy can spark your cat’s natural instincts because you can create a maze of tunnels for your cat to explore, simply by connecting two or more of these crinkly tunnels.

The cat will run throughout the maze, poking their heads out of the little peep holes, and if you have more than one cat, it’s a great way for both cats to interact with one another.

Easyology Pets Premium Cat Tunnel Toy Maze Crinkle Chute in Living Room

The toy is made of a strong material that won’t rip or tear when they are playing, but it’s soft so that it won’t hurt the cat either. This is one of the best cat toys for active cats who like to run, hide, pounce, and hunt.

Some other features of this toy include:

  • Velcro closures for easy storage when playtime is over
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee

People who purchased this product, gave it an excellent rating, which speaks a lot about the product! A common feeling that many reviewers have expressed is that the toy isn’t an ideal option for larger cats.

Another comment other customers shared is the desire to be able to hide the Velcro straps. That, of course, is an easy fix.


Pioneer Smart Cat Ultimate Scratching Post

You might not think that a scratching post should be considered among one of the best cat toys, but the reality is it’s so much more than just a scratching post.

It’s one of those cat toys for indoor cats that will keep them entertained, but it will also save your furniture from being at the mercy of your kitty’s claws.

This post stands at 32” in height, and it’s been designed to maximize the surface space, enabling your kitty to exercise, play, stretch, and of course, mark its territory.

Pioneer Smart Cat Ultimate Scratching Post on White Background

Some of the features of this toy include:

  • Durability
  • Easy to put together
  • It has a sturdy Base

Of the folks who purchased this stand for their fur babies, almost all gave this product an amazing rating. Wow! These consumers shared that the moment the toy was erected and the cats got used to it, they fell in love with it.

Of the very few negative comments, a few have said that the fabric was too stiff and the cat couldn’t get their nails into it without snagging. Since this is a very rare occurrence, we may have to consider this a fluke problem.


Cat Tree Scratcher Play House Condo

If you thought the previous cat scratcher was a great toy, this condo is amazing. With its multi-platform design with steps, cubbies, and fabric wrapped posts, it’s no wonder why cats love this.

Your cat is going to have plenty of space to play, exercise, stretch, scratch, hide, and just have fun. The post is covered in sisal rope to help give it extra stability.

Cats on Cat Tree Scratcher Play House Condo

Some of the features of this toy include:

  • Several perches
  • Two sets of stairs
  • 1 large “shelter.”
  • 1 small “shelter.”
  • A small hanging mouse toy

People who purchased this cat stand, gave the product great reviews. That’s not too bad, right? Many of them shared that their cats thoroughly enjoyed the condo, especially if they owned more than one cat.

Of the negative comments, some consumers said that the product wasn’t sturdy at all, the carpeting covering the toy was cheap, and it smells like chemicals and plastic, which was a big deterrent to the cats.



Choosing a cat toy can be a little overwhelming, especially if you go to a big pet store and you see the long aisle with nothing but toys.

With that said, when you do some careful observation of your kitty, and you take note of their behavior, you can get a good idea of what type of toys they’ll enjoy the most.

Young Cat Playing With Scratch Toy

Of these three products, we have to say our favorite is the scratching post. Not only do other consumers agree, but the simple fact that cats enjoy the post to scratch on is a huge bonus.

After all, don’t we all hate having scratched up furniture or curtains? This toy greatly reduces that!

About the Author YourFamilyPets

Leave a Comment: